Tuesday, October 28, 2014

The Awakening Criticism #1

Spangler's criticism of "The Awakening" by Chopin is accurate in my own personal views. In his critique, he argues that the ending of the book was insufficient because of the strength and continual characterization of Edna as the book went on. Edna being such a complex, growingly strong character, should not have killed herself at the end of the book. The change in characterization from strong to weak was evident, yet inaccurate and against her will. Spangler explains that "Edna suddenly collapses, and what the reader gets in the way of explanation does not follow from what he has witnessed before," therefore making the ending inconsistent with the rest of the story (Spangler 209). The reader can see that Edna's persona has suddenly become lost on the last pages of the story when Chopin writes that "the shore was far behind her, and her strength was gone" (157).  I also agree with how Spangler believes that Chopin ended the book this simplistically because she fears society herself. Just like Edna, she does not theoretically believe in conforming to societal expectations for women, however, she does second guess herself in order to protect herself, just as Edna does when she throws her wedding ring and breaks the glass, yet regrets it later. I believe that Chopin held back in the ending of her story because of the scandalous matter of the story may have put her at harm in her own society, so she punished Edna in order to protect herself from criticism.

Monday, October 27, 2014

The Awakening Dialectical Journal- Final Chapters


“‘After a while,’ he said, laying a
cigar on the table
” (144).

Robert, smoking a cigar in this scene, is very significant in this story, as he graduated to bigger and better things in comparison to his cigarettes that he used to smoke before.  Just as Leonce smoked cigars, Robert begins to smoke cigars too, showing that he is just as much a man, and equal to, Leonce.  This leveling of the playing field ultimately shows a gain in confidence that Robert gains, and may be foreshadowing to a future event in the story.

 "'I love you,' she whispered, 'only you; no one but you. It was you who awoke me last summer out of a life-long, stupid dream. Oh! You have made me so unhappy with your indifference. Oh! I have suffered, suffered! Now you are here we shall love each other, my Robert" (Chopin 147)

Edna’s ability to admit her true love to Robert is an extremely significant turning point in the story, as she is finally admitting to Robert that she loves him.  The strength that Edna has gained throughout the story and Chopin’s continual characterization of Edna and her ability to come to terms with her true feelings ultimately serves as a type of relief for the reader, who has waited the entire story for Edna to admit her love to Robert.  The reader anticipates Robert to admit his love for her, too, yet the reader is in for a big surprise when he later on rejects her. 

“How strange and awful it seemed to stand naked under the sky! How delicious! She felt like some new-born creature, opening its eyes in a familiar world it had never known”

Edna’s strength and characterization comes to an end in the last chapter of the story, as she finally is able to experience what it is like to be free.  Breaking free from societal expectations, symbolized by her nudity, expresses her desire to break free and be one with the ocean, which has been a common theme throughout the story, and a clear representation of her freedom and desire to demolish the conformity that the society she lives in requires the women that surrounds her to follow.

Thursday, October 23, 2014

The Awakening Dialectical Journal Chapters 21-30

"After a refreshing bath, Edna went to bed. And as she snuggled comfortably beneath the eiderdown a sense of restlessness invaded her, such as she had not known before" (99).
Edna's continual action of bathing represents her rebirth and ability to separate herself from Leonce. By bathing, she is cleansing herself both literally and figuratively. By cleansing her soul and her mind she is more clearly able to see that she needs to free herself from her marriage in order to achieve true happiness. 

"The thought was passing vaguely through her mind 'what would he think?' She did not mean her husband; she was thinking of Robert Lebrum" (104). 
The fact that Edna is more concerned about what Robert will think than her husband shows her true feelings of emotion for Robert. This could be foreshadowing that she will allow her feelings to be released from her internal thoughts now that she has enabled herself to admit them for her. Despite this being a small factor in her brain, it is a rebellious thought for the time period and may be the true beginnings of her awakening. 

"'Are you in love with Robert?' 'Yes,' said Edna. It was the first time she had admitted it, and a glow overspread her face, blotching it with red spots" (110).  
When Edna finally admits that she loves Robert, the reader feels a sense of relief and tension lifted. The reader knows all along that Edna loves Robert so her ability to finally  admit her true feelings. This confession for her true love of Robert will ultimately cause issues in society as well as with her marriages, and the scandal may awaken other women as well. 

Tuesday, October 21, 2014

The Awakening Dialectical Journal Ch. 11-20

"'Leonce, go to bed,' she said. 'I mean to stay out here. I don't wish to go in, and I don't intend to. Don't speak to me like that again; I shall not answer to you'" (42).  
Edna's ability to stand up for herself despite her husband's demands ultimately foreshadow a change in her character. This could potentially be the turning point in her relationship and place in society, and she could finally be "awakened" by the realization that she does not always need to conform to her husband's demands, as she is an individual capable of making her own decisions. 

"He had soon joined her. She had never sent for him before. She had never asked him. She had never seemed to want him before. She did not appear conscious that she had done anything unusual in commanding his presence" (44). 
Edna's clear desire to spend time with Robert rather than her own husband is apparent of her true feelings. After her defiance to her husband, she feels liberated and able to do as she pleases. Her subconscious desire to spend time with Robert explains why it was not out of the ordinary for her, as she is only acting on her emotions even if she cannot yet recognize her feelings towards him yet. 

"'We'd share it, and scatter it together,' he said. His face flushed" (47). 
The reader here can easily see that Robert has true respect and feelings for Edna. Because of his willingness to share things with her and enable her to be herself and express her emotions, Edna feels safe and comforted around her. Her openness towards Robert along with her fearlessness to spend time with him despite being married ultimately suggest to the reader that she has a serious feelings for him and these feelings are mutual. 

Monday, October 20, 2014

The Awakening Dialectical Journal Chapters 1-10

"'You are burnt beyond recognition, he added, looking at his wife as one looks at a valuable piece of personal property which has suffered some damage" (3).
This quote shows how women were treated as property and were not looked upon as having their own ability to be individuals. The husband looking at his wife as a piece of property that has "suffered some damage" shows how he does not appreciate her as a person or any of her qualities in general. His feeling of superiority over her is relevant in the society they lived in during this time period. 

"At a very early life she apprehended instinctively the dual life -- that outward existence which conforms, the inward life that questions" (18). 
This quote represents how even as a young girl, Mrs. Pontellier felt that she could not show her true feelings about her place in society. She conformed to what society expected of her despite her internal emotions that made her question what life would be like if treated as an equal to a male. This dual nature and hiding of feelings that she experiences is a normal feeling for many women during this time period. 

"Their absence was a sort of relief, though she did not admit this, even to herself. It seemed to free her of a responsibility which she had blindly assumed and for which Fate had not fitted her" (25). 
This quote shows how Mrs. Pontellier is not content with the life she is living. Even though she does love her children, it is apparent that she does not love the responsibility of taking care of them all the time without the help of her husband. Rather than cherishing the time she spends with them, she appears to dread it and does not want to spend as much time with them as her husband would like her to. Because she is not content with the children, I am assuming that this dislike grows from discontent stemming from her marriage. 

Thursday, October 9, 2014

Happy Endings Structure and Style

"What happens next?"- Rhetorical Question
"John and Mary die. John and Mary die. John and Mary die."- Repetition
"Mary is hurt."- Declarative Sentence
"Mary gets run-down."- Telegraphic Sentence
"Mary falls in love with John but John doesn't fall in love with Mary."- Complex Sentence
"Remember, this is Canada."- Setting
"Her friends tell her John is a rat."- Metaphor
"John will emerge like a butterfly from a cocoon, a jack in the box, a pit from a prune."- Simile
"Inside John, she thinks, is another John."- Split Sentence
"But Mary isn't impressed by him, she is impressed by James" - Characterization

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

"The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas"

In "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas", Ursula Le Guin explores how happiness on the surface may actually be hiding flaws, and does this through setting, symbols and irony.

Le Guin's usage of the mountains as a symbol represent the "Utopian society" as being trapped by the seemingly perfect ideals of the community. The beauty of the town is shadowed by the mountains and in the end of the story, the reader can see that those who escape the town and leave, over the mountains, are overcoming the obstacle of recognizing there are serious problems in the society.  Their ability to recognize these issues, sacrifice their happiness and leave town ultimately impact Le Guin's message.  Not only does the setting of the town in between the mountains, representing the isolation from the outside world, but it also acts as this symbol as well.

Furthermore, the utilization of the setting with the child in the basement who is sacrificing his happiness for the happiness of others.  His suffering and misery in the story inside of the basement symbolize the underlying struggle and sacrifice that must be given in order to achieve happiness.  Because most of the people in the Utopia are ignoring this child's suffering in order to focus on their own happiness, Le Guin hints at a message about humanity and society that comes off as cynical and dark, like the mountains surrounding the town and the basement that the child is trapped in.  This dark side of humanity underneath the happiness and perfection that the reader would expect, therefore utilizing irony, as well. Le Guin's use of irony with the suffering child in the basement of a Utopian society is unexpected from what a reader would picture when thinking about the perfect community.  For this reason, the message that underlying sacrifice is necessary for happiness to occur is relevant and clear.